The town hall of Vallorcine, in Haute-Savoie, has announced it will suspend subsidies to associations that use artificial intelligence (AI), notably to promote their events or activities. According to statements from the municipal council relayed by Le Parisien, the slightest use of this tool would suspend the payment of the aid.
- La mairie de Vallorcine suspend les subventions aux associations qui utilisent l’intelligence artificielle pour leurs événements ou leur promotion.
- Le moindre recours à l’IA entraîne la suspension du versement de l’aide.
- La commune veut soutenir les acteurs locaux et leur travail humain, non celui des machines.
- Les avis sont partagés : certains saluent une mesure écologique, d’autres la jugent trop sévère pour les petites associations.
The municipal council specifies that “the sums allocated as a subsidy must be used to support local stakeholders, and therefore any use of AI for the event and its promotion will suspend the payment of said subsidy.” It adds: “We subsidize human beings and their work, not that of machines.”
A mixed reception
The decision has sparked mixed reactions in the department. On the local Facebook group Chamonix au Quotidien, some internet users welcome “a good decision for the planet.” Supporters of the measure highlight the water consumption of AI, used mainly to cool the servers of its data centers, as well as the electricity consumption required for their operation.
They also welcome the disappearance of posters generated by artificial intelligence, deemed unappealing, which they say would “revalue the work of graphic designers.” Others see it as an “exaggerated” measure for small associations with limited resources. One internet user, on the same group, laments: “I am not for AI, but to go so far as to sanction associations (…) They will be forced to request subsidies to pay for graphic designers.”
For implementation, a new charter, mentioning this provision, must be signed between the municipality and each beneficiary association.
