ChatGPT vs Google Search Ads : Early Data Shows the Gap

ChatGPT vs Google Search Ads : Early Data Shows the Gap

ChatGPT Ads, OpenAI’s advertising platform launched in February, now has a target cost bidding option. According to OpenAI, the product had reached an annualized run rate of $1 billion as of August 31. The question for paid search teams is whether these ads truly compete with Google Search Ads and whether early results justify shifting part of the budget.

The data published to date does not answer the first question. Revenue figures, surveys, and Google’s communications do not show how many dollars have been diverted from Google Search Ads to ChatGPT Ads. The only quantified work on performance is a university working paper covering 102 websites with transaction and revenue tracking.

What Revenue Per Visit Shows

In the United States, paid search generates $2.45 in revenue per session, compared to $0.89 for sessions from ChatGPT ads. The transaction rate per session reaches 1.17% for paid search and 0.37% for ChatGPT. These aggregated figures cover 60 weeks, up to August 22, including up to 28 weeks of ChatGPT Ads sessions for US traffic.

The authors, Kaiser and Schulze, built a statistical model that accounts for site, device type, and week. They conclude that ChatGPT Ads sessions generate a lower conversion rate and revenue per session than paid search. Out of 87 advertisers who used both channels in the US, 84 earned less revenue per session with ChatGPT. The authors themselves describe their work as “descriptive rather than causal”: it describes what sites received from each channel, without measuring what would happen if budgets were transferred. The data was provided by Grips Intelligence, where Kaiser, a former employee, is a scientific advisor. The authors state the company played no role in the research.

Contacted, OpenAI responded that the study “describes an earlier period in the development of ChatGPT Ads and extrapolates the platform’s performance from a small sample.” The group says it has launched new products since, including Target CPA and Target CPC.

The $0.52 Figure

A press release from the Frankfurt School, affiliated with one of the authors, claims that every dollar invested in ChatGPT Ads yields $0.52 in revenue, compared to $3.40 for Google Search. This ratio depends on the click price. For ChatGPT, the cost used is $1.72, from agency Opascope, published in June on a single account and about $60,000 in spending over 15 days. For search, it is the median of $0.72 calculated across 16 accounts, mostly American. This price was not matched with the revenue of each site. The press release does not explain how these two values were calculated.

What Case Studies Say

Several agencies have published their own feedback. StubGroup, for a B2B client, reported a cost per click of $0.76 on ChatGPT versus $10.46 on Google, a cost per lead of $92.21 versus $157.57, and conversion rates of 0.8% versus 6.64%. The agency notes the client has a long sales cycle and they do not yet know the number of customers ultimately generated. Workshop Digital spent $2,319 on ChatGPT Ads without obtaining a qualified lead, compared to two on Google. Brafton, which also sells these services, spent $1,524.11 for 263 clicks and only one form submission. Its director of paid advertising, Zach Shah, believes ChatGPT ads are “priced like search, but seem to behave like paid social.” Jotform, whose case was cited by OpenAI, reports a cost per registration approximately 30% lower than paid search, based on internal July data.

The New Bidding Options

Since November 9, new conversion campaigns that set a cost goal use Target CPA, and new click campaigns can use Target CPC. Intelligent bidding, formerly Maximize Results, sets no cost goal. Max Bid and Max CPC will be removed from existing campaigns on January 1, 2027.

S’abonner
Notification pour
guest

0 Commentaires
Le plus ancien
Le plus récent Le plus populaire
0
Nous aimerions avoir votre avis, veuillez laisser un commentaire.x