How to Evaluate AI Agents in the Enterprise

How to Evaluate AI Agents in the Enterprise
3 min read

An AI agent that impresses in a demo can fail as soon as it’s confronted with real users and real data. In a guide published by Analytics Vidhya, the evaluation of these systems is presented as a five-layer process, ranging from checking the final result to monitoring in production.

According to the guide, an agent can choose the wrong tool, loop on a failing application programming interface (API), expose data it shouldn’t see, or invent a figure in a report. Evaluating an agent is a different exercise from evaluating a language model, because every step between the objective and the result can fail.

Defining what “success” means

Before writing any test, the guide recommends defining success. It suggests answering four questions: what is the task, what counts as completed, what must never happen, and what is the cost of an error. A wrong answer in an internal FAQ is low-cost, whereas a wrong action in a payment agent is not.

This cost sets the level of requirement. A low-risk agent can be deployed with a 90% task success rate, with the other cases reviewed by a human. A high-risk agent may require 99% and above on critical paths, as well as a firm block on certain actions, regardless of the model’s intent.

Five layers to check

The first layer concerns the result: did the agent accomplish the task? The guide advises checking the actual state, for example the calendar, rather than the agent’s statement. The second concerns the trajectory, i.e., the sequence of actions. Two agents can arrive at the same answer, one in four steps, the other in 19, and the number of steps is not enough to distinguish them. We then examine loops, tool choice, parameter accuracy, and how the agent recovers from an error.

The third layer isolates failing components: planner, document retrieval, tools, memory, and response generation. For a Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) system, which relies on external documents, the guide cites recall@k and precision@k metrics. The fourth layer concerns security: injection of malicious instructions into a document read by the agent, data leakage, compliance with access rights and company rules, handling of personal data. The guide insists on one point: permissions must be enforced in the code, outside the model, and never rely solely on the prompt. The fifth layer is operational: latency, cost per task, reliability, and performance under load.

Judges, humans, and metrics

To score results, the guide distinguishes three methods: programmed checks, “LLM-as-judge,” where a language model scores a response against a rubric, and human review. Automatic judges exhibit known biases, such as a preference for the first answer in a comparison or for the longest answer.

Reliability metrics distinguish two indicators. Pass@k is the probability that at least one of k attempts succeeds, while pass^k is the probability that all succeed. In the guide’s example, with an 80% success rate per attempt, assumed independent, the probability that at least one of five attempts succeeds is about 99.97%, versus about 32.8% for all five attempts to succeed. The guide finally recommends reviewing failures each week and adding each new case to the test set.

S’abonner
Notification pour
guest

0 Commentaires
Le plus ancien
Le plus récent Le plus populaire
0
Nous aimerions avoir votre avis, veuillez laisser un commentaire.x