With artificial intelligence, lawyers work faster, but a billing model based solely on time spent can mechanically reduce their fees. This is the observation made by Emilie Poignon, a partner lawyer at Lexwell, registered with the Paris and Barcelona Bars, who advocates for pricing based on the value of the advice.
AI is now used daily in legal work, for researching, comparing, synthesizing, or structuring information. According to the author, certain tasks that required three hours can now be completed in one hour. This increased efficiency can reduce timelines for clients, but it reveals a contradiction: when remuneration depends on the number of hours billed, the firm that works faster risks billing less.
The hourly rate penalizes the most efficient firms
For a long time, time spent constituted a relatively understandable measure. A complex case required more hours, more people, more research, and more exchanges, and the bill reflected this mobilization. AI changes this link between time, effort, and result.
A lawyer can now prepare a documentary summary more quickly, spot inconsistencies in a set of contracts, or organize the first leads for an analysis. The work remains subject to their validation, experience, and judgment, but its execution time decreases.
The paradox lies in the investment. The firm finances tools, team training, data protection, and the definition of internal procedures. This preparation time, which then allows for speed, is not included in any hourly bill. Billed exclusively on time spent, an improvement in service can therefore lead to a mechanical decrease in fees.
The contradiction already existed before AI. An experienced lawyer can often identify in thirty minutes a difficulty that a less seasoned professional will take several hours to understand. This experience, moreover, most often determines the hourly rate of each practitioner.
The client buys a secure decision, not a number of hours
The executive who consults a business lawyer seeks an answer that allows them to move forward: understanding the risks of an operation, securing a contract, preparing a negotiation, or choosing between several options. The value lies in the quality of the analysis, the relevance of the recommendation, and the ability to prioritize risks.
It also lies in taking the context into account, whether internal constraints, the schedule, or tensions between partners. AI can facilitate access to information and speed up certain tasks, but it does not bear sole responsibility for the recommendation and does not spontaneously know these elements. The lawyer’s role is to connect the law, strategy, and the human reality of the company.
According to the author, this evolution does not reduce the value of the advice. It shifts the center of gravity of the service: document production weighs less, while judgment, anticipation, pedagogy, and decision-making capacity become more visible.
Flat fee, phases, subscription: transparency becomes essential
Moving away from the hourly logic does not mean adopting opaque pricing. Article 10 of the law of December 31, 1971, makes fees dependent on the client’s financial situation, the difficulty of the case, the costs incurred, the lawyer’s reputation, and their diligence. Time as such is not listed there.
Several models can coexist. The flat fee suits services with a scope defined in advance, billing by phase suits operations with several steps, and subscription suits the recurring needs of certain companies. A supplementary success fee can be added, the law only prohibiting setting fees based solely on the judicial outcome. The hourly rate retains its place for unpredictable situations.
This change requires firms to better know their costs, define their processes, and present their fees with greater clarity. The author sees AI as a revealer: it highlights an old weakness of advisory professions, the confusion between time mobilized and value created. The real challenge now is to build pricing that is understandable for the client, viable for the firm, and consistent with the reality of legal work.
